Heuristic Evaluation
Synonyms: Heuristic Analysis, Usability Inspection, Expert Evaluation, Expert Review, UX Heuristic Review
Definition
Use cases
- Confusing navigation: An evaluator finds that users may struggle to locate the account settings because the menu labels are unclear.
- Missing feedback: A form submits without showing a success message, leaving users unsure whether their information was saved.
- Risky actions: A delete button removes an account without asking users to confirm their choice.
How it's used in practice
- Choose the rules: Select a set of usability heuristics that fits the product.
- Set the scope: Decide which screens, tasks, or features the team will review.
- Review independently: Ask 3–5 evaluators to inspect the interface separately.
- Record problems: Note each issue, the heuristic it breaks, and where it happens.
- Rate and discuss: Give each issue a severity rating, combine repeated findings, and agree on what to fix first.
Challenges & limitations
- Personal judgment: Evaluators may disagree about which issues matter most.
- Missed problems: Experts can overlook issues that real users may face.
- Limited evidence: An evaluation can point to possible problems, but it cannot show how actual users behave. Follow up with usability testing when needed.
Free resources
- UX Playbook: Cracking User-Friendly Design — 6 reasons why Heuristic Evaluation is essential in UX design
- NN/g: How to Conduct a Heuristic Evaluation — a step-by-step guide to planning an evaluation, reviewing an interface, recording issues, and combining findings.
- NN/g: 10 Usability Heuristics for User Interface Design — Jakob Nielsen's 10 usability rules, with explanations and examples.
