Back to Glossary

Open Card Sort

Synonyms: open card sorting, open sort, generative card sort, exploratory card sort

Do not index

Definition

An open card sort is a research method where users get a stack of content cards, group them however they want, and name each group themselves.
You give them no categories up front. It lets you build information architecture from how users think, in their words, before you lock in a menu.
 

Use cases

Skip it and your navigation matches your org chart. Users hunt for "Billing" under Account, Settings, then Help, then email support.
Examples:
  • Blank sitemap: The team argues over menu labels for 3 weeks. Nobody asks a user, so the loudest stakeholder wins.
  • Jargon labels: A SaaS app files reports under "Insights." Users call them reports, so nobody clicks.
  • Card overload: A study has 120 cards. Participants tire halfway and dump the rest into "Misc."
 

How it's used in practice

  • Pick 30 to 60 cards: Pull them from a content audit, written in plain words.
  • Recruit at least 15 people per user group: NN/g data shows 15 participants reach a 0.90 correlation with results from 168.
  • Mix unmoderated and moderated: Run most online, then moderate 3 to 5 to hear why people group things.
  • Standardize labels first: Merge "Billing," "Payments," and "Money stuff" into one category before you read the similarity matrix.
  • Validate next: Turn the strongest groups into a draft menu and check it with tree testing.
🪄
Common pitfall: Cards that share a word ("Account settings," "Account billing") get grouped by that word. Strip repeated words before launch, or you're measuring your own wording.
 

Challenges & limitations

  • Slow analysis: 20 participants can invent 60 category names. Merging them takes hours.
  • No task context: It shows how people group content. It can't tell you if they'll find a page inside a real menu.
  • Label bias: One vague card name skews every result tied to it.
 

Free resources

Share this post

Get free UX resources

Get portfolio templates, list of job boards, UX step-by-step guides, and more.

Download for FREE
 
 

The best email 📮 for growing 🌱 designers

Honest notes about the work behind the work. Read in 2 minutes, weekly. Free forever.
 
 
     
    notion image
    Join 13,045 designers and get tactics, hacks, and tips.