Table of Contents
- The growing tension between artists and AI
- Copy 1000+ designs straight into Figma
- Why many artists oppose AI-generated art
- The benefits AI brings to creative work
- Adaptation over resistance
- The darker side of AI-generated content ⚠️
- What does the future hold for creative work?
- Finding your place in an AI-influenced design landscape
- 1. Focus on developing a unique creative voice
- 2. Build skills that complement AI
- 3. Learn to use AI effectively
- 4. Emphasize human connection
- Creativity evolves but remains human
- My personal take…
Do not index
Do not index
Read time: under 6 minutes
The growing tension between artists and AI
AI-generated content has created a sharp divide in creative communities. While some creators view AI as an exciting new frontier, others see it as nothing short of theft.
This controversy didn't start yesterday.
Writers felt the first tremors when ChatGPT appeared on the scene. Designers followed soon after, and now visual artists stand at the center of this heated debate. Musicians appear to be next in line.
So what's really happening here? Does AI pose a genuine threat to creative professions, or is this simply another technological shift requiring adaptation?
Copy 1000+ designs straight into Figma
On Mobbin.com:
- Select a flow, or multiple screens
- Click on "Copy to Figma"
On Figma:
- Open the Mobbin.com plugin
- Click on "Paste"
👉 Try Figma Plugin
Why many artists oppose AI-generated art
Critics, especially professional artists, argue that AI isn't creating anything new.
It's copying.
AI models train on massive collections of existing artwork, often without getting permission from the original creators. This means an artist's decades of skill development, unique style, and original vision can be absorbed into algorithms that produce similar work in seconds.
Studio Ghibli's founder, Hayao Miyazaki, stands among the most outspoken critics of AI-generated art. He once described it as "an insult to life itself".
Many working artists share this view, pointing out that AI essentially creates shortcuts that devalue human effort and expertise.
The problem of market flooding also concerns many professionals.
Since AI makes content creation faster and more accessible, creative marketplaces now overflow with quick-produced work. Many artists worry that genuine craftsmanship will disappear beneath waves of mass-produced, AI-assisted content.
Then comes the financial question; AI art platforms often generate profit using datasets trained on unpaid human-created art. Should companies profit from creative work they didn't actually make or pay for?
The benefits AI brings to creative work
From another perspective, AI offers clear advantages.
It increases productivity, allowing small teams to accomplish more with limited resources. Creative professionals can use AI to handle repetitive tasks, giving them more time to focus on the conceptual aspects of their work.
Rather than replacing human creativity, some argue AI works as an amplifier.
The value of creative work appears to be shifting. We're moving from valuing manual execution toward prioritizing original concepts.
Having unique ideas matters more than the ability to execute them by hand. AI might excel at replication, but truly original thinking remains a human domain.
For those concerned about AI "stealing" work—technology has always disrupted established practices.
Photographers once worried about digital cameras replacing film. Traditional artists feared Photoshop would make their skills obsolete. Now AI tools represent the newest wave of disruption.
History suggests adaptation, not resistance, typically succeeds.
Adaptation over resistance
Currently, AI lacks true creativity. It can combine, regenerate, and refine, but cannot originate ideas. Creativity involves more than assembling data points—it requires perspective, emotion, and storytelling abilities that AI doesn't possess.
However, creative professionals can't afford to ignore these tools. Historical patterns show that resistance to technological change rarely succeeds long-term.
The printing press, photography, digital illustration, and word processors—all once appeared threatening to traditional craftsmanship. Yet each time, creative people found ways to incorporate new tools into their work, evolving rather than becoming obsolete.
The actual transformation happening isn't AI replacing human creativity, it's AI making execution more accessible and faster.
What does this mean for creative workers?
If your only professional value comes from execution, concern makes sense. But if you bring original thinking, specialized expertise, or unique viewpoints to your work, AI represents another tool that can strengthen what you already do.
We're entering an era where original ideas carry more value than manual execution alone. Creative professionals who thrive will focus on developing their unique voice, perspective, and ability to generate novel concepts.
AI can produce variations of existing work, but human ingenuity remains essential for pushing boundaries, challenging norms, and creating groundbreaking work.
The darker side of AI-generated content ⚠️
Beyond the artistic realm, AI is raising other serious ethical concerns.
One of the most alarming developments is how AI-generated content is being exploited for harmful purposes. Deepfakes are warping reality, making it impossible to tell truth from fabrication. Political propaganda, reputation-smearing, and even revenge porn are now easier than ever to produce.
But the darkest corners of AI go beyond deception.
Law enforcement is scrambling to fight AI-generated child exploitation materials. Unlike traditional abuse cases, these AI images have no real victims; making it nearly impossible to track down offenders.
Criminals are exploiting AI’s ability to generate infinite, undetectable material, staying ahead of laws that weren’t built for this nightmare.
Then there’s creative theft. AI scrapes, mimics, and monetizes real artists' work without credit. Musicians are battling AI-generated clones of their voices.
This isn’t just about whether AI threatens the jobs of artists, it’s about the broader implications of unchecked, rapidly advancing technology.
If AI can mimic creativity so well, how do we ensure it’s used responsibly?
AI is a powerful tool but without regulation, it’s also a monster with no leash.
What does the future hold for creative work?
AI won't disappear from creative industries. The question isn't whether it will replace creative professionals. It won't.
The real question is how creative workers will adapt. Artists, designers, writers, and musicians maintain advantages in original thinking, emotional depth, and storytelling. AI can replicate but struggles to truly innovate.
The creative industry stands at a decision point: embrace AI as a tool or resist and risk falling behind. Whether you like it or not, AI development continues regardless. Those who succeed will learn to work with these tools rather than against them.
Finding your place in an AI-influenced design landscape
For UX designers and other creative professionals navigating this changing landscape, consider these practical approaches:
1. Focus on developing a unique creative voice
While AI can generate derivative work based on existing patterns, it cannot replicate your personal experiences, cultural background, or unique perspective. Developing and refining your distinctive creative voice provides value AI cannot match.
Practical steps:
- Document your design process and thinking
- Identify patterns in your work that reflect your unique approach
- Consciously develop aspects of your style that differentiate your work
2. Build skills that complement AI
Rather than competing directly with AI's strengths, develop skills that work alongside these tools.
Areas to focus on:
- Strategic thinking and problem definition
- Facilitating collaborative design processes
- Critiquing and refining AI-generated options
- Understanding human psychology and behavior
3. Learn to use AI effectively
Understanding how to leverage AI tools properly can dramatically increase your productivity while maintaining creative control.
Practical steps:
- Generate multiple alternatives quickly to evaluate different approaches
- Refine and personalize AI outputs with your expertise
- Use AI for initial ideation and brainstorming
- Automate repetitive design tasks
Free AI courses on OpenAI Academy:
4. Emphasize human connection
The most valuable creative work often addresses deeply human needs and emotions—an area where AI still falls short.
Practical steps:
- Incorporate storytelling techniques that resonate on a human level
- Conduct in-depth user research to understand emotional needs
- Focus on accessibility and inclusivity considerations
- Build empathy-driven design solutions
Creativity evolves but remains human
The relationship between AI and creativity continues to evolve rapidly.
While these tools reshape how creative work happens, they don't eliminate the need for human creativity. Instead, they shift the focus toward uniquely human capabilities—original thinking, emotional intelligence, and making unexpected connections.
The most successful creative professionals won't be those who resist technological change but those who strategically incorporate new tools while developing distinctly human creative strengths. The core of creativity; the ability to see the world differently and share that vision with others remains fundamentally human.
My personal take…
I’m frankly excited to see the next generation of designers building products with AI. Software that is a delight to use. Software that prioritizes the details. Software that feels great. God knows we need more products differentiated with taste.
Thank you Mobbin for sponsoring. Try it today and sign up for free
Whenever you're ready, there are 4 ways I can help you:
1. Junior Designer Bundle: Transition into UX and craft an unforgettable portfolio & get hired.
2. Senior Designer Bundle: Become a design leader with systems to build healthier, happier teams.
3. UX Portfolio Critique: In less than 48 hours, get your 30-minute personalised video of brutally honest feedback.
4. Job Sprint Course: Stand out in an unpredictable job market by building a memorable personal brand and a killer job search strategy.
